Controversial Judge Seeking Top Post Despite Backlash

Judge Naita Semaj, known for lenient rulings, is seeking a promotion to become the presiding justice overseeing Manhattan and Bronx cases despite criticism.
Victims' rights groups and lawmakers oppose Semaj's bid due to her record of freeing accused criminals and distrust in police.
Semaj has ties to the Bronx Democratic Party and has donated to politicians like Michael Benedetto and Ritchie Torres.
Semaj was elected to the Civil Court in 2019 and the Supreme Court in 2021 but has made several controversial decisions favoring defendants.
Semaj is under investigation for removing a prosecutor from her courtroom during a hearing for an accused 17-year-old gang member.