Eli Manning Misses Hall of Fame Induction in First Year of Eligibility

Despite two Super Bowl MVPs and a storied career, Manning's candidacy faced challenges due to mixed individual achievements and stiff competition.

Eli Manning was not selected for the Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2025 in his first year of eligibility, which included four inductees: Eric Allen, Jared Allen, Antonio Gates, and Sterling Sharpe.
Manning expressed peace with the decision, stating it does not change his outlook on his career, which includes two Super Bowl MVPs and 16 seasons with the New York Giants.
His Hall of Fame case sparked debate due to his postseason success and longevity but was hindered by a .500 career win-loss record and a lack of individual accolades like All-Pro selections or a regular-season MVP.
The 2025 class is the smallest in two decades, and next year's ballot presents significant competition with first-time eligible players like Drew Brees, Larry Fitzgerald, and Frank Gore.
Manning's two Super Bowl victories, including an upset over the undefeated Patriots in 2007, remain defining moments of his career, and many believe he will eventually be inducted in future years.