Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Karen Read Retrial Focuses on DNA Evidence and Expert Credibility

As the trial enters its fifth week, defense challenges forensic evidence and highlights inconsistencies in expert witness credentials.

Karen Read listens to her defense attorney David Yannetti as her trial in Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham continues on Wednesday, May 14, 2025.
Image
Image
Image

Overview

  • Prosecutors presented DNA evidence linking John O’Keefe to Karen Read’s SUV, including findings from a broken taillight and a drinking glass at the scene.
  • Digital forensics expert Shannon Burgess testified about SUV black-box data and timeline reconstruction but admitted to misrepresenting his academic credentials.
  • The defense argues that Read is the victim of a police conspiracy and suggests evidence may have been planted, raising questions about alternate suspects.
  • Testimony revealed that a hair sample found on Read’s SUV matched O’Keefe’s mitochondrial DNA but could also match his maternal relatives.
  • Judge Beverly Cannone allowed newly amended reports and expert testimony despite defense objections over discovery concerns.